Literature Develops Critical Thinking
Critical thinking is the ability to think clearly, logically, and deeply about ideas and evidence. Studying literature is excellent training for this because literary texts are complex, ambiguous, and open to more than one reasonable interpretation. Below we expand each sub-point.
Encourages interpretation
What interpretation means
Interpretation is the skill of working out what a text means beyond its surface story. It involves reading carefully, noticing patterns and details (words, images, repetitions), and connecting those to larger themes, symbols, or ideas.
Why it matters
In life and work, we often must make sense of incomplete information, read between the lines, and weigh different possible meanings. Literature gives repeated practice at this skill.
How to teach interpretation (a step-by-step method)
- Close reading: Start with a single sentence or short passage. Ask students to note striking words, unusual images, repeated sounds, or punctuation.
- Ask literal questions: Who is speaking? What is happening? Where and when?
- Move to inferential questions: What might the speaker mean? What is suggested by the choice of a certain word or image?
- Identify symbols/metaphors: Does anything stand for something else? (e.g., green light in The Great Gatsby may suggest hope, distance, or the American Dream.)
- Contextualize: Consider historical, cultural, and authorial context. How might time or place affect meaning?
- Propose an interpretation: Formulate a clear thesis sentence: “In this passage, the green light symbolizes… because…”
- Support with evidence: Use quotations and explain how each supports the interpretation.
- Consider alternatives: Acknowledge other valid readings and explain why you prefer your view.
Teaches evaluation
What evaluation means
Evaluation is judging the strength of an argument, comparing different ideas, and deciding which view is best supported by evidence. It asks: Is this interpretation convincing? Why or why not?
Why it matters
Evaluation trains judgment — distinguishing strong evidence from weak, spotting assumptions, and making reasoned choices. These are essential academic and life skills.
The building blocks of evaluation
- Compare ideas: Put two interpretations side-by-side and see which best explains the evidence.
- Question assumptions: Identify hidden premises in a reading (e.g., “the narrator is reliable” may be assumed but could be false).
- Analyse moral choices: Consider characters’ decisions and evaluate motives and outcomes.
- Examine perspectives: Whose voice is dominant? Who is missing from the text?
- Evaluate arguments: Test a claim by checking textual support, logic, and context.
Encourages independent thought
What independent thought means
Independent thought is forming an original, reasoned opinion rather than repeating received ideas. Literature, with its openness, requires students to make judgment calls and defend them.
Why it matters
In most real-world situations, there is no single “right” answer. Being comfortable with ambiguity and able to argue one’s point calmly is a key life skill.